Over-the-counter medications: Where do I start?

Woman at pharmacyYou overdid it yesterday throwing the baseball around, and you wake up with searing shoulder pain. Or maybe your lower back pain has returned after sleeping wrong. You head to the grocery store looking for an over-the-counter (OTC) medication and are confronted with an array of options. What should you use? Here’s some common OTC pain medications that may be of use.

NSAIDS (non-steroidal anti-inflammatories)

There are numerous OTC NSAIDs available. Ibuprofen (Motrin, Advil) and naproxen (Aleve, Naprosyn) are readily available, and there’s no advantage to the name brand over generic. NSAIDs work by blocking chemicals that are involved in inflammation and pain. Ibuprofen tends to last around 4-6 hours, while naproxen lasts a bit longer, around 12 hours. If one NSAID doesn’t work well for you, it’s worth trying a different one. NSAIDs do thin your blood a bit, through the same mechanism that aspirin does. Patients on strong blood thinners, with kidney disease, or with a history of GI bleeds should avoid these. If you’re unsure if you can take them, be sure to ask your primary care provider!

Within the past two years, diclofenac gel (Voltaren gel) has become available over the counter. This is a topical NSAID, and only a small amount is absorbed into the system. This is a good option for some patients as well.

Acetaminophen (Tylenol)

Acetaminophen is an OTC pain medication that works very differently from NSAIDs. In fact, we don’t even know the exact mechanism of how it works! It doesn’t seem to affect inflammation directly, but rather affects pain perception. It’s also quite good at reducing fevers. Acetaminophen doesn’t affect bleeding, has no effect on kidneys, and is overall a very safe medication. The daily limit is 3000 mg per day. Patients with liver issues may need to avoid acetaminophen.

Topical medications

These include creams and patches. Think Aspercreme, Biofreeze, Icy Hot, among many others. Aspercreme’s active ingredient is very similar to aspirin. Biofreeze contains menthol, which induces a cooling sensation. Icy Hot contains menthol, but also camphor, which causes a warming sensation as well. There are also various formulations with lidocaine, a topical anesthetic with a numbing effect. An interesting medication in this class is capsaicin cream. Capsaicin is the substance in hot peppers which makes them spicy. Some patients may find the cream uncomfortable, but it works by essentially exhausting your small nerves in the region for a bit.

This is certainly not an all-encompassing list. And by all means, look at the active ingredient in the medication and comparison shop for generics. As long as the active ingredient is found in the same concentration, it should work just as well to help your pain. Hopefully this has been helpful for next time you find yourself walking through the Rx isle!

Mark Jordan, MD
About Dr. Mark Jordan

Dr. Mark Jordan provides orthopedic services at Door Orthopedic Center in Sturgeon Bay. The Door Orthopedic Center at Door County Medical Center is a state-of-the-art facility paired with a top-notch orthopedic team that can get you back to daily living and your favorite activities as soon as possible. To schedule an appointment at Door County Medical Center's Door Orthopedic Center, visit our Door Orthopedic Center page or call Door County Medical Center at 920-743-5566.

Published 9/23/2021 7:00:00 AM
Tags: Dr. Mark Jordan, health tips, medication, news

Search our blog

Popular Tags

3D Mammography   75   75th   acid reflux   addiction   adrc   advance directive   Affective   alcohol   Algoma   Algoma Community Wellness Center   als   alzheimer's disease   Ambassador   American College of Healthcare Executives   Angel Ball   anniversary   antibody treatment   anti-bullying   apnea   art   art for health   art gallery   arthritis   athlete   athletic edge camp   athletic trainer   Auxiliary   award   awards   Awareness   back   behavioral health   bone marrow transplant   Bravo   Breast Cancer Awareness Month   breast cancer prevention   breastfeeding   Brian   brussels sprout slaw   Burkitt Leukemia   C.H.I.P.   cancer   cardiac   cardiopulmonary services   care manager   catholic   catholic sisters   Celebrate Community   celebration   center   Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services   ceremony   certification   childcare   children   cold flu prevention   colon cancer   colonoscopy   community   community health   Community outreach   Coronavirus   COVID 19   COVID-19 booster   COVID-19 vaccine   critical access hospital   CT scanner   cyberbullying   da Vinci robot   da Vinci Surgical System   Daylight Savings Time   DCMC   DCMC Auxiliary   DCMC staff   dementia   dental clinic   dentist   depot   depression   diabetes   diagnostic imaging   Diana Wallace   diet   Disorder   dogs   Domestic Violence Awareness   donate   donor   Door County   Door County CARES   door county half marathon   Door County Meals Cooperative   door county schools   Door County Triathlon   Door County YMCA   Door Healthy Weight Center   Door Orthopedic Center   Dr. Daniel Tomaszewski   Dr. Elizabeth Gaida   Dr. Mark Jordan   Dr. Michael St. Jean   Dr. Reisner   Dr. Rory Johnson   Dr. Shaun Melarvie   drive-through clinic   e-cigs   economic impact   economy   Edge 3D   Education   emergency department   employee art   employment   environment   environmental stewardship   exercise   fair   Family   family medicine   family practice   farmer's market   first responders   fitness   five   five star hospital   Florence Nightingale   flu   foot   foot pain   Foundation   fundraiser   gallery   gardening   Gerald   GERD   gynecological procedures   handwashing   happy holidays   head   health   health tips   healthcare   healthcare leader   healthcare leaders   healthy eating   heart   heart healthy   heart-attack   heartburn   Heartburn and Reflux Center   Help Our Heroes   hernia   hernia screening   hip replacement   history   HOPELINE   hospice   hospital   House and Garden Walk   HPV   Human Kindness Project   immunization   infant   insomnia   internships   job   jody boes   joint replacement   June   kelsie ladick   kids   Kids' health   kim   knee replacement   Lab Drive-Thru   LEAP   lice   life   LifeAssist   living will   luke spude   lyme disease   mammography   marinara sauce   medical services   medication   memory   memory clinic   memory loss   men's health   men's health month   mental health   mental illness   milk   ministry   ministry fund   mission and values   MRI   National Donate Life Month   national heath decisions day   national hospital week   National Nurses Week   National Organ Donation Day   National Women’s History Month   navigator   New Year   newborn   news   non-profits   North Shore Medical Clinic   novel coronavirus   nurse   nursing   nursing excellence   nursing program   nutrition   nwtc   obesity   OB-GYN   OPSU   organ   organ donor   orthopedics   outpatient surgery   outreach   patient   patient care   Patti Balestrieri   Paula Hobart   pediatrics   pelvic health   pets   physical activity   physical therapy   podiatrist   post exercise tips   PRC   Prevea   prevention   primary care   Providers   race   recipe   recovery   reflux   rehab services   resolutions   respiratory illness   robotic surgery   rotator cuff repair   RSV   running   rural   rural healthcare   SAAM   SAD   scholarship   scholarships   school   School Nursing   Seasonal   senior life solutions   senior therapy   Seniors   services   sexual assault   Sexual Assault Nurse Examiner   Shop and Dine Day   Sister Bay   Sister Bay Clinic   skilled nursing   skilled nursing facility   skin cancer   Sleep   sleep disorder   sleep lab   smoking   snf   social justice   specialty providers   sports   sports medicine   sports training   St. Francis   star   state-of-the-art   Stephens   stroke patients   studer group   suicide awareness   suicide awareness month   suicide prevention   summer   summer programs   sun care   surgery   sweet dreams   swiggum   technology   Teen health   Teens   telemedicine   teleNICU   telepediatrics   The Angel Ball   The Community's Garden   The Healing Project   ticks   tissue donor   to   training tips   Treatment   triathlon   urgent care   vaccination   vaccinations   vaccine   vaping   virtual appontments   virtual visit   volunteers   wall   Washington Island   wellness   Wendy Ulrikson   women's center   women's health   work injuries   world breastfeeding week   Worrick   wound care   years   YMCA   youth workshops